Control Group Study
External Impact Assessment
Our team collects extensive data to evaluate the effectiveness of our program within the communities we serve.
Year after year, we’re encouraged to see that Seed Effect members are improving their lives in every sector we are measuring. And now, thanks to an independent control group study recently completed by Dr. Steve DeLoach of Elon University, we can see how these results compare to the general population.
Seed Effect members, Benson and Flora, hold their chicks with pride.
The couple raises chickens to sell eggs in the market and feed their family.
Comparing Seed Effect Members to Non-Participants
In 2018, Dr. DeLoach began an independent impact assessment of Seed Effect’s program to examine whether Seed Effect members experienced increased self-reliance and empowerment compared to non-participants in the same communities. DeLoach’s control study consisted of 1,491 individuals surveyed between 2018 to early 2020. This included 939 South Sudanese refugees and 552 Ugandans.
Results of the study support that Seed Effect’s program does have significant positive effects for both refugee and host community participants. DeLoach’s review includes the impact of participation on asset accumulation and reports that “relative to non-participants, members of
Seed Effect’s groups on average experienced significant increases in most asset categories over the course of one year.”
As seen in Figure 2, non-participants reported a decrease in the value of livestock owned while Seed Effect members experienced a significant increase (+628% in comparison) as detailed in Table 1. This increase, DeLoach found, is seen in both the refugee and host community participants alike.
DeLoach notes that this is especially important because of the unique challenges facing refugees. He writes, “Because refugees have been forced to leave their communities and livelihoods, they are likely to lack the social structure to support them economically. Seed Effect offers opportunities to accumulate savings and wealth to build livelihoods and insure against major expenses.”
Seed Effect member, Abraham Chandiru, with his wife on their family farm
“Overall, the relatively large impact revealed in this assessment underscores the value of Seed Effect’s program within the UNHCR’s refugee aid and development framework by demonstrating the viability of groups as an important mechanism to promote refugee self-reliance.”
DeLoach concludes,
“By providing [Seed Effect] training and opportunities, refugees are able to become self-reliant by accumulating wealth that insures them against unexpected emergencies…”
Article Info
Share This Article
More From The Blog
Our 3-Year Model
Since Seed Effect’s inception in 2009, we’ve been committed to empowerment. And if we’ve learned anything, it’s that empowerment takes time… especially in the hard places. While current solutions to refugee crises do not often lend themselves to restoration, Seed...
Inside The Box
Each Seed Effect Savings & Loan group receives a secure metal box filled with the necessary tools for establishing a safe place to save. These tools, combined with the long-term guidance of our indigenous staff, promotes holistic poverty alleviation. Bible Study...
New Partnership: Seed Effect & Equipping Farmers International
When people hear the name Seed Effect, they often assume it is an agricultural organization. For years, we’ve explained that it’s a metaphor for the economic and spiritual impact we’re making in the lives of our members. But now, that’s all changing as Seed Effect is...